Hope this helps

I’m an insurance agent in Michigan 🙂 I would keep at least comprehensive on your vehicle – it usually doesn’t cost that much and if you have a broken windshield, if the car is stolen, you hit an animal/deer, or someone vandalized the car or it caught on fire, it would be covered under comp.

Usually with collision, I delete it on my vehicles when they are worth less than 1200.00 – 1500.00, or if the collision price adds up to more than the value of the vehicle in a year. I do that knowing that if I have an accident that’s my fault, I won’t have coverage, if someone else hits me and it’s their fault, I know that I can go against their insurance for up to the maximum of $1000.00 mini-tort for the damages done to my car. Of course, a lot of people drive without insurance, so you could be screwed.